Lead Developer, Stardock Entertainment
(Spoilers contained)
Published on November 5, 2003 By CariElf In Movies & TV & Books
As I left the movie theater today after seeing the Matrix, I felt much the same as I do leaving church on Good Friday. It's rather like leaving after a funeral. Except that you have the added guilt of knowing that it's your fault, and the fault of countless generations before you that Christ had to die on the cross. (Catholics really get into the guilt factor on Good Friday). On Good Friday, I know that Easter is coming just a few days away. But I always ask myself, was it worth it?

I had predicted before the movie started that Neo was going to be a Christ figure and have to die to save the human race. But I was rather hoping that I was wrong. I know that it was necessary, and that Neo will probably be reborn in the Matrix, but I still feel the loss. The Wachowski brothers were able to create incredibly real, likeable characters, and they brought us into their world. They could have made a stirring movie in which, despite all odds, all the major characters survived. But it wouldn't have been believeable. Matrix Revolution was about a war, and people die in wars. People we can't afford to lose. It also asks us the question, "Why do we keep living? Why do we fight to survive?" So while part of me desperately wanted a happier ending, with Neo and Trinity there looking at the sunset, I find greater value in the ending, where Trinity and Neo sacrificed themselves for the rest of humanity. The Wachowski brothers dared to go beyond entertainment to give us something to think about. More power to them. Their trilogy is a great, powerfully, masterfully told story, and I wouldn't have them change it for all the money in the world. It has a depth that goes far beyond what Star Wars tries to achieve.

I don't expect to change anyone's opinion of the Matrix Revolution with this blog. I'm just stating my own. Form your own opinion.
Comments
on Nov 05, 2003
i wanted at least trinity to live too!
on Nov 05, 2003
Real, likeable characters??? Hrm....

I think the most realistic character of the whole bunch was Cypher perhaps.
Likeable? Let's see. Mouse. Tank. Dozer. Well, I guess those guys don't really count for much.

The rest of the characters were far from what I'd call -likeable-. In fact, they were all pretty damn unlikeable when you considered how little they valued the lives of their fellow humans, even if those people -were- people "trapped" within the Matrix. For people who viewed themselves as the saviours of humanity, they sure didn't mind slaughtering them wholesale in the movies (at least the first one.)
on Nov 05, 2003
Mouse was annoying, but only in the sense that most adolescents are annoying. Given time to grow up, he probably would have turned out ok. I liked Tank and Dozer.

These people were soldiers. Any of those people in the Matrix could be and were used against them as soon as one of the programs took them over. The programs used people still trapped in the matrix like terrorists strapping bombs on little kids. The greater good isn't pretty. It isn't fair. It isn't easy to see. And how often in movies do people have enough time to weigh all alternatives and come up with the best answer, if there even is one? Or in real life? Wars suck. Innocent people die.

Who was it who said, "Life sucks, and then we die?" It's bitter, it's cynical, and searching for the originator of that little pearl brings up some disturbing hits on google. I know it's on a T-Shirt. It can also be true if we let it. The Matrix trilogy was all about what that statement is lacking: hope. Hope is what makes life worth living.

on Nov 05, 2003
did you two ever see the movie "clerks"? there was one scene where the two main characters are discussing return of the jedi and the destruction of the second death star...

RANDAL
Well, the thing is, the first Death
Star was manned by the Imperial
army-storm troopers, dignitaries-
the only people onboard were
Imperials.
DANTE
Basically.
RANDAL
So when they blew it up, no prob.
Evil is punished.
DANTE
And the second time around...?

RANDAL
The second time around, it wasn't
even finished yet. They were still
under construction.
DANTE
So?
RANDAL
A construction job of that magnitude
would require a helluva lot more
manpower than the Imperial army had
to offer. I'll bet there were
independent contractors working on
that thing: plumbers, aluminum
siders, roofers.
DANTE
Not just Imperials, is what you're
getting at.
RANDAL
Exactly. In order to get it built
quickly and quietly they'd hire
anybody who could do the job. Do
you think the average storm trooper
knows how to install a toilet main?
All they know is killing and white
uniforms.
DANTE
All right, so even if independent
contractors are working on the
Death Star, why are you uneasy with
its destruction?
RANDAL
All those innocent contractors
hired to do a job were killed-
casualties of a war they had
nothing to do with.
(notices Dante's confusion)
All right, look-you're a roofer,
and some juicy government contract
comes your way; you got the wife
and kids and the two-story in
suburbia-this is a government
contract, which means all sorts of
benefits. All of a sudden these
left-wing militants blast you with
lasers and wipe out everyone within
a three-mile radius.
You didn't ask for that. You have
no personal politics. You're just
trying to scrape out a living.

The BLUE-COLLAR MAN joins them.

BLUE-COLLAR MAN
Excuse me. I don't mean to
interrupt, but what were you
talking about?
RANDAL
The ending of Return of the Jedi.
DANTE
My friend is trying to convince me
that any contractors working on the
uncompleted Death Star were innocent
victims when the space station was
destroyed by the rebels.
BLUE-COLLAR MAN
Well, I'm a contractor myself. I'm
a roofer...
(digs into pocket and
produces business card)
Dunn and Reddy Home Improvements.
And speaking as a roofer, I can say
that a roofer's personal politics
come heavily into play when choosing
jobs.
RANDAL
Like when?
BLUE-COLLAR MAN
Three months ago I was offered a
job up in the hills. A beautiful
house with tons of property. It was
a simple reshingling job, but I was
told that if it was finished within
a day, my price would be doubled.
Then I realized whose house it was.
DANTE
Whose house was it?
BLUE-COLLAR MAN
Dominick Bambino's.
RANDAL
"Babyface" Bambino? The gangster?

51.
BLUE-COLLAR MAN
The same. The money was right, but
the risk was too big. I knew who he
was, and based on that, I passed
the job on to a friend of mine.
DANTE
Based on personal politics.
BLUE-COLLAR MAN
Right. And that week, the Foresci
family put a hit on Babyface's
house. My friend was shot and
killed. He wasn't even finished
shingling.
RANDAL
No way!
BLUE-COLLAR MAN
(paying for coffee)
I'm alive because I knew there were
risks involved taking on that
particular client. My friend wasn't
so lucky.
(pauses to reflect)
You know, any contractor willing to
work on that Death Star knew the
risks. If they were killed, it was
their own fault. A roofer listens
to this...
(taps his heart)
not his wallet.



of course the security guards were merely ignorant of what they were protecting, but hell, it's just a movie...
on Nov 05, 2003
LOL, I'd forgotten about that conversation.
on Nov 06, 2003
"The programs used people still trapped in the matrix like terrorists strapping bombs on little kids. "

BUT - they originally had the ideals of freeing the people from the Matrix as well. Yes, I imagine it -would- be easier to rationalize 'killing' somebody when in reality you know they're just some body in a pod, but still...
I won't mention that Neo wasn't a soldier... and what, no comment about my picking Cypher as the most 'real' person in the movie? hehehehehe

Oh man! Now I'm wanting to see Clerks again. So unfair - one of the many movies I want, and don't have...
on Nov 13, 2003
The first Matrix was a *great* popcorn flick, but that's all it was. The next two were crap. As for Star Wars, the entire series is crap.